Anna Maria IsLand's
Award Winning Ice Cream

The Best Ice Cream on the IsLand

Flavors

Banana Cream Pie:

Creamy Banana ice cream with marshmallow ribbon and baked pie crust pieces

Bear Claw:

Dark intense Chocolate ice cream with thick ribbon of caramel and chocolate

Black Cherry:

The ultimate original Deep Black Cherry ice cream exploding with Bordeaux cherries

Bubble Gum:

Bubble Gum flavored ice cream loaded with gumballs

Butterscotch Bomb:

Butterscotch ice cream drenched with a thick ribbon of butterscotch and exploding with brownies, heath bars, cookies and peanut butter cups

Butter Pecan:

Butter Pecan ice cream loaded with lightly salted, roasted pecans

“C” is for Cookie:

Vibrant blue Vanilla ice cream loaded with cookie dough pieces and crushed cookies

Captain’s Chocolate:

Smooth, triple rich, award winning Chocolate ice cream (a house favorite!)

Caramel Caribou:

Toffee ice cream overflowing with a thick river of caramel and mini chocolate caramel cups

Calypso Crunch:

Rich Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter filled chocolate covered pretzels in a river of peanut butter

Cookies ‘N Cream:

Scrumptious Cookie flavored ice cream with crushed chocolate cookies in every bite

Cookie Dough:

Sweet Cookie flavored ice cream loaded with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips

Dreamsicle:

Sweet Vanilla ice cream & tangy Orange Sherbet swirled together

Elephant Ear:

Vanilla ice cream swirled with peanut butter & oversized chocolate chips

Mint Chip:

Refreshing Mint ice cream with large, rich chocolate chips

Garbage Can:

Vanilla ice cream with generous chunks of 7 different brand name candy bars and granulated peanuts

Purple Daze:

Black Raspberry ice cream with a black raspberry crinkle, and dark chocolate black raspberry cups

Pistachio:

My Brother’s all time favorite….the Ultimate Pistachio ice cream loaded with roasted pistachios…perfection!

Rum Raisin:

Fantastic Rum flavored ice cream loaded with raisins

Salty Caramel Peanut:

Salty caramel ice cream with a salty caramel ribbon and salty roasted peanuts

Stellar Coffee:

Rich Coffee ice cream with delicious fudge and mini dark chocolate coffee cups

Strawberry:

Creamy Strawberry ice cream with chunks of strawberries and a strawberry swirl

Superman:

Vanilla flavored ice cream in vibrant red, yellow, and blue colors

Toasted Coconut:

Toasted Coconut ice cream with mounds of toasted coconut flakes

Vanilla:

Our Grand Master Award winning smooth & creamy Vanilla ice cream

Watermelon:

Chilling Watermelon Sorbet…..it’s summertime in each scoopful! (Non-Dairy)

More Options

Sorbets/Ices

No Sugar Added

Vegan

Non-Dairy

Probiotic Frozen Yogurt

Allergy friendly J

Rotating Flavors

We rotate certain flavors to insure everyone has their favorite treat!

Carrot Cake:

Carrot Cake ice cream with fresh walnuts and a thick ribbon of cream cheese frosting

Cheesecakes

Different variety of cheesecake ice creams that rotate!

(pictured: blueberry cheesecake)

Cotton Candy:

The carnival kicked up a notch…..Cotton candy flavored ice cream loaded with colorful mini M&M’s.

Gold Mine:

Rich Chocolate & French Vanilla ice cream swirled together with a caramel ribbon

Hawaiian Fruit Cup:

Tropical Coconut ice cream with pineapple chunks and strawberries….a truly refreshing treat!

Heavenly Hash:

Rich Chocolate ice cream swirled with creamy marshmallow, butter-roasted almonds & chocolate chips

Key Lime Pie:

We’re based in South Florida so we know Key Lime done right……..Delicious Key Lime ice cream filled with chunks of baked pie crust

Mac Daddy Coconut:

Missing a Hawaiian getaway, Coconut ice cream with macadamia nuts swirled with fudge and butterscotch.

Mackinac Turtle Fudge:

Butter Pecan ice cream with roasted pecans, chunks of butter pecan fudge, and a Mackinac classic butter pecan fudge swirl.

Mexican Hot Chocolate:

Mexican Chocolate ice cream with a pinch of cinnamon, tons of mini marshmallows, and a cayenne kick

Mint Trax:

Mint ice cream with mini chocolate mint cups and a rich ribbon of fudge.

Peanut Butter Cups:

Classic Peanut Butter ice cream loaded with crushed Reeses® Peanut Butter Cups and swirled with a creamy peanut butter ribbon

Raspberry Truffle:

Raspberry ice cream with raspberry ribbon and dark chocolate raspberry cups

Red Velvet Cake:

Red Velvet ice cream with chunks of decadent red velvet cake and a rich ribbon of cream cheese icing