Featured Items

Small Town Creamery’s October Fudge Special.  Buy 1 pound of fresh
homemade fudge and get a ½ lb free!

Fall in Florida means it’s time to enjoy Maple Walnut and Penuchi Fudge
(Brown Sugar Fudge with a hint of maple)

Halloween Wiffer Sniffers are here!  Limited quantities available.

The perfect salty sweet lunch.  Nathan’s famous hotdog or sausage
nestled in a warm toasty Belgian waffle

Our Story

Business partners Dennis and Lindy believe the best things on earth come from small towns. Fresh local ingredients, friendly hard working people, and small town charm all come together to create an unforgettably delicious experience for you and your family.

Dennis and Lindy have one super power in common. They each have an incredibly strong passion for wholesome tasty goodness. Dennis’ search for the sweet life started in NJ and ended here on the sweet little island of Anna Maria. Dennis has spent the last 15 years tirelessly searching for obscure little treasures of deliciousness.

Lindy’s job with the Military brought her from New England, to California, DC, NY, and countless places in between. With each move she sampled and tasted and tasted yet again the bounty of remarkable sweetness the country has to offer.

As you can imagine, after decades of scouring the planet for that perfect little something sweet and satisfying, Dennis and Lindy have cultivated quite the discriminating pallet.

These fearless dessert warriors both agree and the research confirms the yummiest food always comes from that small hole in the wall strip mall shop that could easily be overlooked. This discovery coupled with their unrelenting super human passion for the tastiest treats inspired them to create Small Town Creamery.